Features

Tim Bonner: Drop the dead deer

Written by Tim Bonner | Nov 18, 2026, 5:26:15 PM

I am not sure I would be that keen on roadkill muntjac in June unless I knew that death had been very recent, but I certainly would not expect to be prosecuted for retrieving a deer. This is what happened to photographer, Guy Carpenter, who was prosecuted by Durham Police for collecting a deer from beside the A66. 

If you are determined to be very technical, a dead deer on a central reservation belongs to the Highway Authority but, given that such rotting carcasses litter our road network, the idea of prosecuting someone for clearing up the obvious mess would seem to be mad. That is even before you dial in the lack of resources regularly cited by Durham constabulary. The prosecution might have been dropped after the police became embarrassed about media coverage, but the story reveals something about policing priorities and a general ignorance of rural issues.

It might seem a leap to connect the police’s reaction to the snaffling of a dead deer with the re-organisation of the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, but there is a link. Defra Permanent Secretary, Paul Kissack, recently posted about a re-organisation of the department into three large groups: Water and Marine; Farming, Land and Nature; and Food Biodiversity and Trade. The class swots amongst you will have noticed the discrepancy between these groups and Defra’s title because, despite nominally being the department for ‘rural affairs’, it seems to have no interest at all in rural people.

In fairness this is nothing new. Successive governments have paid lip service to the interests of people who live in the countryside, but then found representing them in government far too difficult. Tony Blair talked up ‘rural proofing’ but then banned hunting, David Cameron abolished the Commission for Rural Communities, Boris Johnson handed Defra to the animal rights movement and Keir Starmer started a war on the countryside by accident.

In the 25 years since Defra was created there has rarely, if ever, been a time when the rural community has felt that its interests were being championed by the department. Secretaries of State have focused on the environment, on farming, on food, but never on delivering an equal standard of service, investment and outcome for those who live in the countryside.

The Alliance has made the case for rural community impact assessments, a rural champion scrutinising policy across government departments and an annual State of the Countryside report. It is frankly extraordinary that we are having to ask a department that purports to have responsibility for rural affairs to introduce such policies, but given that it has not, we cannot be surprised that bodies like the police and the justice system have so little regard or understanding of perfectly normal rural behaviour.

If the state is to treat rural people sensibly and fairly, the countryside needs a champion in government and the proposed reorganisation of Defra certainly does not look as if it is going to deliver that.